Pixoo vs Shopify Native Discounts: When to Use Each

If you're running an international Shopify store, you've likely encountered the challenge of managing discounts across multiple currencies and markets. Whilst Shopify's native discount system is robust for single-market operations, it has limitations when dealing with global commerce. This is where specialised solutions like Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts come into play.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll compare Pixoo's multi-currency discount capabilities with Shopify's native discount features, helping you determine which solution best fits your business needs.

Understanding the Core Difference

Before diving into the detailed comparison, it's crucial to understand the fundamental difference between these two approaches:

Shopify Native Discounts are built into your Shopify admin and work seamlessly for stores operating in a single currency or those comfortable with automatic currency conversion based on exchange rates.

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts is a specialised app designed specifically for stores that need to create currency-specific and market-specific promotions without relying on automatic conversions.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Currency-Specific Discounts

Shopify Native Discounts:

• Discounts are created in your store's base currency
• Automatically converts to other currencies using live exchange rates
• No control over exact discount amounts in different currencies
• Can lead to odd pricing (e.g., £7.43 off instead of £7.50)

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts:

• Create separate discounts for each currency
• Set round numbers for each market (€10 off in EU, £8 off in UK, $12 off in US)
• Full control over discount values in every currency
• Maintains psychological pricing advantages

Winner: Pixoo - Essential for maintaining clean, market-appropriate pricing

Market-Specific Promotions

Shopify Native Discounts:

• Limited market targeting capabilities
• Cannot create market-exclusive promotions easily
• Difficult to run region-specific campaigns

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts:

• Full market restriction capabilities
• Create US-only Black Friday deals whilst running different promotions in Europe
• Target specific Shopify Markets with tailored offers
• Exclude certain markets from promotions entirely

Winner: Pixoo - Critical for sophisticated international marketing strategies

Discount Types Supported

Shopify Native Discounts:

• Percentage discounts
• Fixed amount discounts
• Free shipping
• Buy X Get Y
• Automatic discounts
• Discount codes

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts:

• Amount off products (currency-specific)
• Amount off orders (currency-specific)
• Free shipping (market-specific)
• Buy X Get Y (with currency-specific values)
• All integrated within Shopify's discount interface

Winner: Tie - Both support essential discount types, but Pixoo adds currency specificity

Ease of Setup and Management

Shopify Native Discounts:

• No installation required
• Familiar interface for all Shopify users
• Simple, straightforward setup
• Limited configuration options

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts:

• One-click installation from Shopify App Store
• Integrates directly into Shopify's discount tab
• Familiar interface matching Shopify's design
• Additional configuration options for currencies and markets
• 7-day free trial to test functionality

Winner: Shopify Native for simplicity, Pixoo for flexibility

Pricing Considerations

Shopify Native Discounts:

• Free with all Shopify plans
• No additional costs
• No limits on discount creation

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts:

• Free for development stores
• £15.99/month for Business plan
• £19.99/month for Shopify Advanced
• £29.99/month for Shopify Plus
• Unlimited discounts on all paid plans
• 7-day free trial

Winner: Shopify Native for cost, but Pixoo's ROI often justifies the investment

When to Use Shopify Native Discounts

Shopify's native discount system remains the best choice when:

1. Single Market Operations

If you primarily sell in one country or currency zone, native discounts work perfectly. There's no need for additional complexity.

2. Percentage-Based Promotions Only

When running exclusively percentage-based discounts (e.g., 20% off), currency conversion isn't an issue, making native discounts sufficient.

3. Budget Constraints

For new stores or those with tight budgets, starting with native discounts makes sense until international sales justify additional investment.

4. Simple Discount Strategies

If your promotional strategy doesn't require market segmentation or currency-specific values, native discounts handle the basics well.

5. Testing International Waters

When first expanding internationally, native discounts let you test market response before investing in specialised tools.

When to Use Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts

Pixoo becomes essential when:

1. Running True Multi-Currency Stores

If you've enabled local currencies in Shopify Markets and want customers to see clean, round discount amounts in their currency, Pixoo is indispensable.

2. Market-Specific Campaign Requirements

When you need to run different promotions in different regions—such as Singles Day in Asia, Thanksgiving in North America, or Boxing Day in the UK—Pixoo enables precise market targeting.

3. Maintaining Psychological Pricing

For brands that understand the importance of pricing psychology (£9.99 vs £10.00), Pixoo ensures your discounts maintain these advantages across all currencies.

4. Shopify Plus Operations

Shopify Plus merchants with complex international operations will find Pixoo's advanced features align with their sophisticated needs.

5. Competitive Market Positioning

When competing with local businesses in international markets, having market-appropriate discount values (rather than converted amounts) appears more professional and trustworthy.

Real-World Scenarios: Making the Right Choice

Scenario 1: Fashion Retailer Expanding to Europe

Challenge: UK-based fashion brand wanting to offer €50 off orders over €200 in EU, whilst maintaining £40 off orders over £150 in UK.

Solution: Pixoo - Native discounts would create awkward converted amounts like €46.73, undermining the promotional impact.

Scenario 2: Digital Products Store

Challenge: Selling downloadable products globally with occasional 25% off promotions.

Solution: Shopify Native - Percentage discounts work universally without currency-specific concerns.

Scenario 3: Seasonal International Campaigns

Challenge: Running Black Friday in US/Canada, Singles Day in Asia, and Boxing Day in UK/Australia simultaneously.

Solution: Pixoo - Essential for managing multiple market-specific campaigns with appropriate cultural and currency considerations.

Scenario 4: Small Craft Business

Challenge: Primarily domestic sales with occasional international orders.

Solution: Shopify Native - International sales volume doesn't justify additional investment yet.

Integration and Compatibility

Shopify Native Discounts

• Works with all Shopify themes
• Compatible with most apps
• Integrated with Shopify Analytics
• Works with Shopify POS

Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts

• Seamless integration with Shopify's discount interface
• Compatible with all Shopify Markets settings
• Works alongside native discounts for maximum flexibility
• Supports all active Shopify currencies
• Maintains compatibility with other Shopify apps

Making Your Decision: A Practical Framework

To determine which solution fits your needs, consider these questions:

1. Do you sell in multiple currencies?

   • Yes, with local currency display → Consider Pixoo
   • Yes, but showing converted prices → Native might suffice
   • No → Use Native

2. Do you need market-specific promotions?

   • Frequently → Pixoo essential
   • Occasionally → Pixoo recommended
   • Never → Native sufficient

3. What's your international sales percentage?

   • Over 30% → Pixoo strongly recommended
   • 10-30% → Consider Pixoo based on growth trajectory
   • Under 10% → Native likely sufficient

4. What's your average order value?

   • High AOV → Pixoo (ROI easily justified)
   • Medium AOV → Evaluate based on volume
   • Low AOV → Consider Native initially

The Hybrid Approach: Using Both Together

Many successful international Shopify stores use both solutions strategically:

• Native Discounts for simple, universal promotions (percentage-based sales, storewide events)
• Pixoo for sophisticated, market-specific campaigns requiring precise currency control

This hybrid approach maximises flexibility whilst controlling costs.

Getting Started with Pixoo

If you've determined that Pixoo's multi-currency capabilities would benefit your store, getting started is straightforward:

1. Install Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts from the Shopify App Store
2. Take advantage of the 7-day free trial
3. Create your first currency-specific discount directly from your Shopify admin
4. Monitor performance and adjust strategies based on market response

The app integrates seamlessly with your existing Shopify discount workflow, requiring no technical expertise or complex setup.

Conclusion: Choose Based on Your International Ambitions

The choice between Pixoo and Shopify native discounts ultimately depends on your international commerce strategy:

Choose Shopify Native Discounts if:

• You're primarily a domestic seller
• International sales are incidental
• Budget is a primary concern
• Your discount strategy is simple

Choose Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts if:

• International sales are strategic to your growth
• You need professional, market-appropriate promotions
• Customer experience in local currencies matters
• You're running sophisticated multi-market campaigns

For most growing international Shopify stores, Pixoo's modest monthly investment (starting at £15.99) quickly pays for itself through improved conversion rates and customer satisfaction. The ability to create genuine, market-specific promotions that resonate with local customers is invaluable for serious international expansion.

Remember, you can always start with Pixoo's 7-day free trial to test how multi-currency discounts could transform your international promotional strategy. With unlimited discount creation and dedicated support across all plans, it's a risk-free way to explore advanced discount capabilities.

---

Ready to take your international discounts to the next level? Try Pixoo Multi-Currency Discounts free for 7 days and see the difference currency-specific promotions can make for your global sales.